Chapter 1
The first moment
You know, it is mind-boggling to think about the very first moments in our lives. For a young child, it’s hard to think about the past or future. A three-year-old struggles to understand yesterday and tomorrow, and it’s almost impossible for them to imagine that there was life before theirs. Pictures can help, sure, and stories, too, but those might feel like fairytales for kindergartners.
Conversely, adults are better at thinking about time as a linear chain of events. We can imagine that something will happen tomorrow and plan for it. We can remember past events and put our memories into perspective, learning from them. We’re also pretty good at picturing life centuries ago. Humanity spends a significant amount of time researching history. Yet, as we dig deeper into the past, a mysterious element creeps in—there’s evidence, but we can’t avoid theories and educated guesses.
We need to patch these gaps to see the bigger picture. And the further back we go, the fewer clues remain. Going back to the invention of printing, we have a lot of written evidence (though, granted, not everything written is a fact). It’s still easier to piece together events if several people documented them. Before printing, we rely on handwriting, pictures, hieroglyphs, and beyond a certain point, only objects remain as evidence. Earlier than that, we turn to geology and astronomy. We can go back incredibly far, almost to T=0, the very first moment of our known universe.
To be more precise, we have evidence until about the first 10^-13 seconds after the Big Bang, and we have grand theories that push further back to around 10^-43 seconds. That’s unimaginably close to the theoretical “first moment.” How small is that? Well, the distance light travels in that time (on the order of 10^-34 meters) is tiny compared to the size of a hydrogen atom (about 10^-11 meters). So we’re close but not quite there. Physics and its laws fail at that level. Even if we knew what happened at time zero, we wouldn’t know what happened at time minus one. What was before the “Big Bang”? What started it? Who started it?
We have a similar problem with evolution. We have evidence for how Homo sapiens evolved from hominins around 300,000 years ago and how mammals emerged about 200 million years ago. We can trace back to around 3.5–4 billion years ago when single-celled organisms like bacteria appeared, but then we hit a black hole in our timeline. The Miller-Urey experiment (1953) showed that essential organic molecules, amino acids, could be created in early Earth-like conditions. Still, these are just the necessary ingredients, not the fully complex components like nucleotides (the building blocks of DNA and RNA).
So, we can go back quite far, but we still don’t know the first moment. How was life created?
In this book, I’ll go backwards from decisions through psychology to neuroscience, but I won’t explain how thoughts are born. Why not? Because we can trace our brain activity down to the neurotransmitter level—how neurons communicate through electrical and chemical signals—long before our conscious mind becomes aware. Yet beyond that point lie theories and philosophies about the origin of thought itself, and I don’t plan to dive into that territory.
To give you, dear reader, a small taste of what different schools think about the origin of thought:
- Dualism (René Descartes): Suggests there’s a physical and a non-physical (a soul). Decisions, in this view, originate in the soul.
- Spiritual and Religious Beliefs:
- Soul-Centred Theories: Many traditions say actions stem from a soul, spirit, or divine influence, not just biology. Christianity, Islam, and Judaism often emphasize the soul and holy will.
- Karma and Reincarnation: In Hinduism and Buddhism, actions (karma) are part of a spiritual journey that extends across lifetimes and may go beyond physical chemistry.
- Determinism and External Forces:
- Some theories propose that actions are shaped by external factors—social, cultural, or divine—rather than internal chemistry.
- Sociocultural Determinism: Actions come from societal norms and upbringing.
- Theological Determinism: All actions are preordained by a divine being.
- A critique is that removing individual agency conflicts with what neuroscience and psychology often show.
So let’s agree not to agree. Let’s be satisfied if, for now, we focus on understanding our daily workings at the physical level. This approach might help us deepen our understanding of ourselves, and if we hold spiritual beliefs, it might even enrich that non-physical connection.