Stupid Biases
I’m reading The Psychology of Stupidity, and like most readers, I’m starting to realize how stupid I’ve been—especially when it comes to decision-making. As Oscar Wilde, Bertrand Russell, Francis Bacon, and even Nietzsche pointed out, maybe humans are the least rational species of all. On the bright side, I’m not alone in this realization. At least I can recognize my own stupidity. But there’s a catch: I almost always come to this realization just a moment too late, after the decision has already been made.
As a construction worker once told me, "Being wise in hindsight? How cute," when I said that we should have dug deeper before filling up the parking area with gravel.
But why does this happen? Why can’t we catch that moment between trigger and response? Why can’t we be mindful in real-time, even though mindfulness has been gaining popularity since the 1980s and became mainstream in the 2000s? By now, we should have mastered it. But, alas, we haven’t.
It turns out, that not only are some of our coworkers lazy, but our brains are also pretty lazy. It’s always looking for shortcuts. Maybe it’s because the brain requires so much energy that we can’t sustain it with just chocolate and coffee all day. To save energy, our brain skips deep thinking and opts for shortcuts—what psychologists call heuristics. These heuristics help us make fast decisions, but they often lead to cognitive biases.
We know these biases, even if we don’t always call them by name. We feel them when we recognize a mistake, but we’re experts at spotting them in others. As I mentioned earlier, we tend to see them in hindsight.
One funny, almost unbelievable example of how stupidly effective biases are is the study where participants were influenced by irrelevant information—random Social Security numbers—when placing bids. Yes, a random number affected their decision-making! (This is called anchoring bias.) What? Are we really that stupid? Or maybe it’s efficient?
Then there’s the more relatable confirmation bias, the one that kicks in when you’re searching for your next washing machine, TV, or pair of headphones. You scour comparison websites, gather user feedback, and look at raw data, eventually narrowing down your options from 10 to 5 to 2. But in the end, you somehow end up choosing the one you always wanted. Hours spent confirming the decision you’d already made. Am I alone in this? Studies say no.
Let’s look at something closer to management: the sunk cost fallacy. This is when decisions are based on the idea that "we’ve spent too much to stop now." You’ve likely heard variations of this, such as "We’ll finish because we started," or "We won’t quit until I’m in charge." Escalation meetings are often full of these types of statements. Add some anchoring bias and overconfidence effect to the mix, and you’ve got a typical agile status meeting.
If you want more proof that you’re not (and your colleagues aren’t) a total idiot, just search for cognitive biases. But before you dive into Google, let me warn you: there are 180-200 cognitive biases that have been identified. With so many out there, it makes you wonder—are they really errors? We seem to use them more than our logical brain processes, so maybe they’re just part of how we think. While I’m not the first to ask this question, until there’s a definitive answer, grab some popcorn and learn to live with them.
Here’s the kicker: you can know about biases, you can even study them, but your brain still won’t care. You’ll still check your watch twice when you want to know what time it is. You can’t force your brain to think differently but like many things in life, habits can help.
Awareness, training, and practice can reduce the frustration of only being wise after the fact. You need post-mortems, retrospective analysis, data-driven decision-making, and an environment where your fellow irrational humans provide feedback. So instead of just awareness, training, and practice, I could say: recognize, study, teach, and repeat.
Be aware when you or others around you are acting irrationally, and when you notice it, don’t just say "Don’t be stupid." Study the most common biases, understand the basic reasons behind them, and teach those around you with patience and care.
At the end of the day, you won’t be perfect, but with some practice, you’ll be just a little less stupid next time.