Change, Stress, Performance
Imagine yourself in the following situation:
You are overwhelmed with your daily tasks. Also, at home, the situation could be in better shape. You will solve it, but you need some time for it. But your boss is just asking for something extra urgent. Meanwhile, you receive mail from a close colleague at another location, distracting you. It goes on seven days a week and 365 days per year. Oh, and you are feeling yourself only a tiny little part of the vast machinery, the colossal organization you are part of, only one of the 50.000 employees.
But, you finished for today.
Walking home after this crazy day at work, you hear political news on the streets. What the politicians are doing nowadays and how divided the population is disgusts you. And you know that in the city, clerks organized a protest for this afternoon. This situation puts some more weight on your shoulders.
The next day is the cherry on the cake: reorganization due to acquiring a new field.
I assume, but I can not be 100% sure that you haven't imagined yourself in a tunic or toga, have you?
I described a typical stressful day for a Roman worker in the bureaucracy, a clerk or a scribe 2000 years before.
Their daily routine was similar, not just the stress they met with. Even the word stress was used first as a psychological term in the 1920s by Janos Selye; the changes they found themselves in caused similar feelings. We know some sage quotes from Roman times:
- "Optimum est pati quod emendare non possis." "It is best to endure what you cannot change."
- "Malum consilium quod mutari non potest." "It is a bad plan that can't be changed."
In his book Meditations, Marcus Aurelius dedicated his message to around 40% of the book to discussing change.
If we are at a company, big or small, like the Roman bureaucracy, we have a certain status, a job to be done, and known connections. In its peak time, the Roman bureaucracy, this vast organization, had more than 30.000 "employees" with around 8 hierarchy levels. At the top, instead of the CEO, the emperor directed the enterprise, and similarly to today's golden rule, with a span of control between 5 and 10.
Although there are many similarities, we know that because of their intensive writing culture and the fact that the Latin language was never wholly lost, we can not dig deep into their change-handling methods.
Change has been part of life on Earth since the beginning; without it, we could not even exist. However, our fixation on performance and economic output is new. It came with the Industrial Revolution and the investigation of every possibility to increase our productivity, even managing the changes formed in the 20th century.
Social psychologist Kurt Lewin formulated one of the earliest models of change management that is still referenced quite prominently today in the 1940s. This was one of the first frameworks to humanize the change management process.
We know now that change undoubtedly causes stress, and feelings of uncertainty mediate this connection.
If an organizational change is poorly managed, we can not be surprised if it negatively impacts the employees' well-being or mental health. Sometimes, it is even better to proceed in a slightly uncomfortable but well-known environment than accept that we will lose our role, job, or colleagues.
Stress, mental issues, and decreasing well-being will unavoidably lower trust, engagement, and performance.
It is proven that high-stress levels can cause a drop in working memory performance, attention, and cognitive control, resulting in a cognitive deficit.
Let's imagine a manager sitting higher in an organization, having 2-3 or even more hierarchical levels between their position and the working group. What can they see? Without generalizing all managers, we can accept that only the numbers about the performance may arrive at their table. What is problematic with the performance loss compared to the stress level of the colleagues is that the first one is easily monetizable, unlike the second. The alerts will be louder when the company's productivity falls and the throughput is halved. Actions have to be taken, bold actions, to show the management's capability even in critical situations. Which are the most common actions in these cases? Changes. Companies are experiencing multiple transformations in their business models, strategies, and structures within just a few years.
It's a vicious circle. Oversimplified: Change causing stress, stress causing performance drop, performance drop makes the bed for new changes.
If the changes are not handled properly, they can incur huge costs. I mean, it is really huge (see the collection at the end)
What shall we do? Changes are needed, you say. The world is changing so fast, you say, so we need to adapt. I agree, but as managers, we are in charge of handling and translating the changes inside the organization.
The above costs can be eliminated or decreased dramatically if a change is managed correctly.
It would be boastful to think that all managers know the tools and methods for a well-oiled transition. What has undoubtedly changed since the Roman age is that many management, psychology, and sociology experts have worked on how to handle changes. Change management is a continuously growing study, and newer methods are popping up. Some things are expected in them; whether we are talking about Kotter's 8-step model, developed by John P. Kotter in 1996 or the ADKAR model, published by Jeff Hiatt in 2003, we know that preparation and communication are essential.
Other similarities are the unfreeze-change-freeze steps, which were the base of earlier mentioned Lewin's 3-step 80 years ago.
Involvement is also a crucial part of several change management methods. Moreover, the fact that all individuals handle changes differently means that management should consider this as a potential opportunity rather than a difficulty.
So, after analyzing some change management strategies and trying out several methods on the field, I can highlight the following as a minimum set of tasks dealing with changes to avoid the change-stress-performance drop vicious circle:
0. Make sure you need to change.
- Assess
- Involve
- Communicate
- Repeat!
So, you thought I could load something into your head that can be used immediately. The problem is complex, so the solution also can not be straightforward. Your situation requires a unique resolution. You, me, and all the others will need organic answers, but to have an organic effect, you need a broad set of tools and knowledge.
Please try to avoid the trap of easy solutions.
It may sound appealing to change the organization and seem trivial from the manager's chair, but it is far from the reality for all employees. Then, we consider ourselves open-minded leaders with critical thinking skills and self-development abilities. In that case, we can fall into the other trap: reading a book and knowing the solution people need in our environment. Bzzzzzzz, red flag, potential cruel optimism on the horizon!
What is cruel optimism? To be continued...
(not so) Fun Facts:
- $1 trillion each year due to lost productivity. Based on WHO observation, it is the global cost of depression and anxiety on the economy. (How much is $1 trillion? Enough for funding the building of around 300,000 high schools or losing the entire economic output of a significant country every single year simply because of mental health issues.)
- Only in the U.S. is $300 billion annually lost to absenteeism, diminished productivity, and accidents (The American Institute of Stress, "Workplace Stress"). (That's enough money to send every American college student to a public university for a year, tuition-free. Or think of it this way: it's like a large company with 100,000 employees losing $3 million yearly.)
- SHRM (Society for Human Resource Management) conducted a study and found that replacement costs can be 100-150% of the employee's annual salary. Considering that more than half (56%) of the workforce is likely to look for a new job in the next 12 months, up from 51% in 2022, according to Bankrate's 2023, this can be a tremendous expense.
- And check this: Gallup estimates that disengaged employees cost the U.S. $450 billion to $550 billion annually in lost productivity.