Quadrants of Belief
When you approach any new organizational changes and are sure that they are inevitable, you are also aware of the potential consequences. This awareness equips you with the necessary knowledge to find the proper tools to implement these changes. If you come across a book, essay, article, or rumour about a change process, you will soon be introduced to the concept of cruel optimism, even if you have never heard the term before. This understanding will prepare you for the challenges ahead, making you feel more prepared and informed.
In 2011, the year of the Fukushima catastrophe and the loss of Steve Jobs, Lauren Berlant completed a book titled Cruel Optimism. However, the book discusses it as a social-demographic issue since the 1980s, the term has now become widely accepted as a description of persistent hope in something unlikely achievable based on the available evidence. Good examples here are oversimplified mental health advice and magic diets, which are optimistic, offering the hope of flourishing, but also cruel, as they neglect or delay evidence-based treatments, as in the case of Jobs.
Johann Hari gives several examples of cruel, optimistic ideas in his Stolen Focus book. One thing worth highlighting to understand the problem is the belief in self-discipline alone:
Based on the mainstream mantra, if you are spending way too much time on social media and you are just scrolling mindlessly to reach the unreachable bottom of the page (see some Fun facts at the end of this post), it is mostly your fault, it is because you are weak, your self-discipline is underdeveloped. For the total truth, we need to accept that in front of our phones, we are "fighting" along with an armada of social, psychological, and engineering experts working day in and day out for years to beat our "underdeveloped" self-discipline. So it is at least cruel to say you should just put down the phone once the environment, massive machinery around you, is trying to reach the opposite.
It is still optimistic because the solution to this enormous social problem is seemingly easy: put down the phone, have a digital detox, meditate, be mindful, and spend time with loved ones. Who won't agree? But it is far from that easy.
Management books are the same. Amazon and all the still-existing real-life new-book-smelling bookstores are packed with books, offering the latest and only one solution for your organization's problem. They state that you must read them and do what they describe step-by-step.
However, I must admit that another cruel optimistic idea, the "magic diet", can have a natural effect.
The first decision is that the "patient" needs a diet. The motivation has built up, and somebody wants to lose weight. Almost all super diets or magic pills deliver fast results, essential for the companies selling them. The patient is impatient and, therefore, unwilling to try something other than a simple diet or a little more exercise. So, here you go: three pills per day, and drink this shake twice daily for four weeks, and you will lose fat.
Why do these solutions often yield results despite all ethical advice to the contrary? Those who try them are not doing so in isolation. Other aspects of their lives are changing, and the results speak for themselves despite the fact that the patient could have used the money elsewhere.
And we shall not forget about placebo, the 13th-century word, which evolved from the original Latin "[I] shall be pleasing" through the act of singing "placēbō Dominō in regiōne vīvōrum", "[I] shall please the Lord in the land of the living". Someone singing these on funerals, acting like knowing the deceased to get the benefit of the funeral meal, to the medical term in the 18th century to describe a treatment given more to please the patient than to provide any therapeutic benefit. In summary, it is a word to a lie, but a lie we all know.
Still, placebo is a well-known and investigated treatment with real effects.
When you spice cruel optimism with all the activities you are doing in addition, and you serve it in one plate with a placebo, you will arrive at the Homeopathy of Management books.
Homeopathy works. It works for a certain level because when you treat yourself with a homoeopathic pill when you are ill, you will likely pair it with other treatments (tea, healthy food, rest)o, and a placebo supports you strongly. However, avoiding evidence-based solutions becomes increasingly dangerous and costly after the patient crosses a particular border. Health starts to decrease when an organ or organization can not heal and needs external help, which is denied.
We could find several examples of this in our lives, but now I focus on management books, especially the ones dealing with changes.
In 2024, Amazon stores a list of more than 1 million books in business and self-help genres. How do you select the proper one? How can you choose any? Who to trust? The best-selling, to best reviewed, the one your neighbour proposed, which was promoted in your favourite podcast? It is too many, and if you are not giving the books away after ten pages as Yuval Noah Harari, your lifetime will not be enough. So, you must assess them critically, not cure yourself and your organization with a homoeopathic management book.
I concluded the following:
We have high and low potential or promise beliefs, and we can treat them based on the provided outcome, which can be positive or negative.
Yes, it is oversimplified and subjective, but at least it can start some thought on your side.
If you want to be critical, it's worth to give a shot. Let's discuss these four categories (or quadrants if you are a more visual type) of management practices:
High promise, high outcome - Empowering evidence
- Here, we can list the evidence-based management books, studies and proven methodologies.
- Examples could be Agile Methodology or Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) for Leadership Development.
High promise, negative outcome - Magic powder
- Cruel optimism, homoeopathy, and superficial management books provide solutions for all problems. The secrets of being rich in three steps or being a good leader in two weeks are examples. Motivational seminars or Top-Down management approaches are also examples.
Low promise, high outcome - Slow Sustainable
- These are the basic, time-tested principles, like Daniel Pink's "Drive" or Stephen R. Covey's "7 Habits."
- Here, we can list management practices like regular performance reviews, transparency, and mindfulness programs.
Low promise, negative outcome - Danger Zone
- Shall I list them? Cynicism, superstitions, "this is how we've always done it," avoidance of innovation due to fear of failure, and a culture of blaming.
So, when you are alone with your struggles, you must be aware that you are vulnerable and you are a target of several cruel-optimistic advice. I am not saying everything that promises fast recovery or increased prosperity is a lie, but at least be critical. Management methodologies are similar. In front of changes, try to appreciate the complexity of the individuals and organizations. As we learned from Stephen Covey:
"With people, slow is fast, and fast is slow."
Quality over speed.
Appendix:
Infinite scroll
You may find interesting this post from 2006:
https://web.archive.org/web/20120606053221/http://humanized.com/weblog/2006/04/25/no_more_more_pages
Or this one from 2008:
https://www.paulirish.com/2008/release-infinite-scroll-com-jquery-and-wordpress-plugins/
And some munition to make it clear, what it causes:
https://health.clevelandclinic.org/everything-you-need-to-know-about-doomscrolling-and-how-to-avoid-it